Skip to content

Leave Us a Review

Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.

Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.

What our customers say about us...

Teresa Bundrum

February 25, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Teresa Bundrum
"I've had the pleasure of working with Scott Warren as my agent during the past several months. Hurricane Ian flooded my car and it was a total loss. When I purchased a vehicle to replace it, Scott guided me through the process of transferring my auto insurance to my replacement vehicle. So many things since the hurricane have been a challenge and a struggle, but Scott made the auto insurance process easy and stress-free. He answered all my questions clearly and really listened to me. When I talked with him, Scott always gave me his undivided attention. Scott made me aware, without pressure, of some excellent options to take advantage of on my auto insurance that gave me much better coverage at minimal extra cost. He has a way of explaining insurance terminology so that it's easy to understand. Thank you, Scott Warren and Tim Collier State Farm Agency, for the confidence you've provided me on my auto coverage. I truly appreciate your skill and personal attention. Teresa Bundrum Pine Island - St. James City, Florida"

rj solis

February 25, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by rj solis
"I am 60 years old I have had insurance for 40 years I don't know why I didn't go to State farm first they treat you really nice and it's a good insurance"

Mic S

February 17, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Mic S
"Macy Flett is an attentive , thorough and very helpful representative. She helped us on numerous occasions. I would recommend her to anyone."

Rod Van Genderen

February 17, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Rod Van Genderen
"Kayla provided great and timely service. We appreciate it and it was very helpful."

Cody Griffin

February 16, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Cody Griffin
"Your search for auto, home, flood, or whatever insurance you need stops with Tim Collier State Farm. The service is incredible and the rates cannot be beat. Joseph Morales was the agent I worked with and his knowledge, service, and willing to work through multiple issues is unmatched. He went above and beyond to ensure that I got the coverage I needed at the best rates possible. He easily saved me $600, if not more, over the next year. The dude just kills it. Be sure to ask for him when you call."

Judy Dicosta

February 15, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Judy Dicosta
"Sean Lucas is by far the BEST BEST Representative with State Farm I have EVER had Not just once but time and time again Sean goes above and beyond from a vender bender back in 2022 to today with a billing error that took place Sean makes time, is genuinely concerned and cares I will honestly say I would follow his service any where he went thru any problems he has come thru like no one else I can not even give this young man enough accolades sincerely Judy DiCosta fantastic representative"

Spencer Hall

February 15, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Spencer Hall
"Extremely happy with the service at the Collier agency, in particular Nicole...she has the perfect personality to be in the marketing field, friendly, bubbly while maintaining a professional demeanor...from the service before Ian changed things up a bit, but especially after the mess and confusion! Thank you to the staff and especially Nicole!"

Alissa Russo

February 14, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Alissa Russo
"Greg at this office was super helpful in getting my fiancé quoted. I have my auto insurance with them, and now with us getting married it only made sense to add him. Saving him a few hundred dollars a year by making the switch!"

Hugh Jessop

January 29, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Hugh Jessop
"I moved to Florida, in 2018 and bought a home in Cape Coral. I learned that the Tim Collier, State Farm Agency was held in high regard by clients. Having been with State Farm (Indiana) for better than 45 years, I opted to insure my home with State Farm. My history for claims over the years, was close to nonexistent and I believed my good fortune would continue. Wrong! Hurricane Ian arrived and the world as I knew it changed. Fortunately, I had opted for hurricane windows and garage door three years ago, and they paid off. My home had minimal damage. My biggest concern was the roof, I contacted State Farm and the staff was very gracious and timely. My initial contact was in Texas and was less than helpful. However, without comment from me, I was transferred to Ms. Lena Williams in Atlanta, she was excellent. Quickly advised me about how to properly file a claim and documentation. Providing the documentation electronically was difficult, likely due to my lack of computer skills, that was when I went to State Farms local office and was greeted by a receptionist, she was courteous and quick to direct me to Mr. Scott Warren, State Farm agent. Note, I had no appointment and they were swamped, but Scott listened to my concerns regarding filing all the proper forms and documentation. He made it clear in the first few minutes that he would take over sending Ms. Williams all the paperwork, documentation and pictures that supported my claim. Since all of this was time sensitive, I was amazed at his willingness to take on all this added work, but he did. Within one business day all of the documents arrived in Atlanta and he had them organized so that everything made sense and was orderly. I met with Scott on at least three occasions, always with additional documents that needed to be sent to Atlanta electronically, each time with the same result, complete acceptance by the claims office in Atlanta. Scott Warren did an amazing job of making this entire process tolerable for me. He is not only an exceptional agent for Tim Collier, he is ethical, caring, exceptionally skilled at his job and one of the most customer friendly professionals I have ever met. I hope that Tim Collier's State Farm office recognizes that Scott Warren is the type of agent every client would like to interact with. Great job, Scott and thank you for your efforts on my behalf. Dr. Hugh J. Jessop"

Gail Patten

January 26, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Gail Patten
"Special thanks to Tim Collier Agency and my Agent Joseph Morles for the assistance in filing a claim. Joe is very responsive and knowledgeable."

Conny Koroll

December 18, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Conny Koroll
"I had issues getting help with an insurance when I bought my house, I should have gone straight to Tim Collier and State Farm...Kayla Nunley gave me excellent service and solved my problems with a smile."

Beatriz “Jewelry girl” Licea Schmidt

October 29, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Beatriz “Jewelry girl” Licea Schmidt
"I'm always treated with a great deal of professionalism... Special thanks to Brandi Matkovich, Gary, Macy Flett, Jolene, Natalie. Wonderful products! I love doing business here and recommend Tim Collier State Farm to everyone!"

Rachel Stokes

October 26, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Rachel Stokes
"Tim Collier is the BEST to work with! I've never encountered an issue with State Farm. I was completely taken care of after this recent monster hurricane Ian. Thank you for caring so much! 💗"

Jamie Steffey

September 14, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Jamie Steffey
"Called them and was immediately transferred to Kayla. Not only did she save us over $250 per year but gave us better coverage. She was very responsive with communication. She did what she said she would do. I highly recommend them."

Elaine Burns

September 1, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Elaine Burns
"Everyone is so nice and friendly and helpful...Elaine Burns"

Joanna Kaye

August 6, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Joanna Kaye
"On a couple of occasions I got into a jam and needed help fast on purchasing insurance. I spoke with Brandi and she was exceptional at her job. She was friendly and courteous and considerate towards my immediate needs. Also others at the office were just as nice."

Theresa Weir

July 21, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Theresa Weir
"I have been with this agency for 15 plus years. I always ask for Sean Lucas, as he is always so helpful, kind, and professional."

Bob Angermeier

July 20, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Bob Angermeier
"Kayla did a tremendous job helping us secure our homeowner’s while Tyler initiated a lot of the legwork. Kudos to both for their support!!"

Shannan Davis

May 22, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Shannan Davis
"Brandi helped us so much with our transition from out of state. Absolutely the best customer service. Above and beyond, always. I even went to register my car thinking a digital copy would be enough, Brandi made sure that my proof was printed out and ready for me to pick up. I made the call BEFORE office hours! We had a terrific agent in CT and now we found another great one!"

MsIdea 1967

May 2, 2022

2  out of  5 rating by MsIdea 1967
"I switched to a different State Farm agent. Some of the girls here have been condescending, and I have no patience for that. I really did enjoy working with Scott; he's my favorite! And Brandi was helpful and professional."

Barbara Passy

April 5, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Barbara Passy
"Thanks and I am very very grateful to Brandi at Tim Collier for making my Florida move so much easier. From the first call, Brandi answered all of my questions clearly. I didn’t have a clue about this stuff. And from Brandi, I learned what mattered and what did not. What a pleasure to work with this truly nice person!!!! Brandi listened and then asked me the questions that needed to be asked. All of that time spent and assistance is so important to me.Florida insurance is very different than anything else I had ever seen before. Again, very very grateful for the excellent and kind service that I received for all of my insurance needs. This is my one stop for insurance. Thanks again!!!!!"

Blink & Co. Photography

March 23, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Blink & Co. Photography
"Jolene, Scott and Greg are wonderful to work with. They are quick to answer emails and everything is always seamless with them regarding my home and business insurance. We have had some hiccups with a previous insurance and they went above and beyond to help us fix the issue. Thank you for your excellent customer service!"

Roxana MGorman

March 9, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Roxana MGorman
"Nichole has been a great asset in assisting me with an application filing for a friend. Through continuous updates and other factors she help resolve the issue. Thank you"

JMC Landscaping

March 7, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by JMC Landscaping
"We had a great time working with Joseph Morales. He is responsive and knowledgeable and was able to save us a very good lump sum of money on our premium. I will refer anyone to State Farm that is looking for great coverage and great prices."

Dennis Funderburg

March 1, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Dennis Funderburg
"I got great service response time from Brandi Matkovich. She answered all my questions in an above average time. I would recommend talking to her directly."